Note: This put up incorporates tons of spoilers for Black Mirror: Bandersnatch, so if you have not watched it, learn on at your individual threat.
One of the earliest decisions in Bandersnatch is a little bit of a lure. The feature-length Black Mirror episode can also be a choose-your-own-adventure story, and this early alternative works to show viewers unfamiliar with the idea of branching narratives about how the idea works. It’s successfully a direct recreation over that leads to restarting the story, however the dead-end department early in Bandersnatch additionally hints at one of many interactive episode’s most fascinating underlying concepts.
The alternative is simply the third that viewers come throughout, when Stefan (Fionn Whitehead) first arrives at Tuckersoft and is obtainable an opportunity to work with the corporate, and his recreation developer idol Colin Ritman (Will Poulter). Stefan has been engaged on an intricate recreation known as Bandersnatch that is all about making decisions and following numerous branching paths. When the Tuckersoft guys provide Stefan the possibility to work with them, viewers can both select for Stefan to throw in with the corporate or proceed engaged on the sport alone.
It appears probably that most individuals would select to hitch the corporate, which is, seemingly, Stefan’s dream and a super end result. The bother is, selecting to work within the Tuckersoft places of work places Stefan on the whim of Mohan Thacker (Asim Chaudhry), whose largest considerations are getting the sport out on time and on finances. Stefan finishes the sport but it surely’s compromised, skinny, and much from his authentic imaginative and prescient.
It’s by far the least painful of the endings for Stefan, which get far more tragic from right here, however a helpful instructor for viewers–as Stefan watches a TV present that critiques video video games and hears about all of the weaknesses of his recreation, he tells his dad (Craig Parkinson) that he will “try again.” Stefan storms out of the room, and a second later, reawakens in his mattress initially of the movie, getting ready once more for his preliminary go to to Tuckersoft.
What’s fascinating about Bandersnatch is the way in which the movie builds its interactivity into the narrative. It’s not simply that you just return to key moments within the narrative and decide totally different decisions to see how issues will play out otherwise; there’s one thing deeper at work within the story, and among the characters develop into conscious that they have been pressured down a number of totally different paths. As that first dead-end path suggests, Stefan is conscious of his skill to return in his story and try a unique outcome–essentially, to time journey. What he is aware of and when he is aware of it’s laborious to trace, although.
A later dialog between Stefan and Colin lays out some model of what is underlying Bandersnatch: a number of, parallel realities. Colin mainly likens the world to Stefan’s recreation, the place all decisions can be found, and in different timelines, Stefan can attempt these decisions and produce them to their conclusions. What’s necessary is not the person timelines, based on Colin, however how they affect one another, and over the course of Bandersnatch we see Stefan seemingly being influenced an increasing number of by these failed timelines and our decisions in creating them.
How Stefan accesses these alternate universes isn’t actually clear, however they do give him some restricted skill to time journey, and seemingly to take at the least some information and familiarity with these different timelines with him. Whenever Stefan fails to attain his optimum path, he finds himself resetting to that first day when he heads to Tuckersoft. Again, it isn’t clear how a lot Stefan is aware of or remembers–but since we the viewers are making his key choices and we are able to keep in mind what occurred, we’re capable of assist him navigate towards higher outcomes.
Like plenty of time journey tales, although, for Stefan, time journey virtually all the time makes issues worse. Every time he hits a narrative lifeless finish and restarts, the adjustments are likely to escalate the horribleness of his life as he tries to finish Bandersnatch. One path leads to him killing his father; one other alternative after that finds Colin arriving at Stefan’s dwelling as he is making an attempt to cover the physique, which may lead Stefan to kill Colin. In truth, there are plenty of endings that end in Stefan partaking in some form of carnage.
And for all of the timelines Stefan accesses, there’s one highly effective remorse he can by no means take again. That’s the loss of life of his mom, who was killed in a prepare derailment after she was delayed by a five-year-old Stefan searching for a toy his father had hidden from him. Stefan blames his dad for his mother’s loss of life, in addition to himself, and that occasion informs nearly every thing about him all through the story. Tellingly, a flashback lets the viewer go to the moments earlier than Stefan’s mom’s loss of life, the place we’re prompted to cease searching for the toy and go together with her, or keep and seek for it. It’s the one alternative in Bandersnatch with just one possibility, as a result of irrespective of how a lot Stefan needs to vary it, he cannot.
Looked at as an entire, it may be form of robust to trace the throughline of what Bandersnatch is getting at. There’s an entire divergent storyline through which Stefan involves imagine he is being monitored and managed by a authorities conspiracy; one other has him stricken by the supernatural demon from Bandersnatch. Still one other reveals to him that he is truly managed by Netflix viewers, which takes him to a few bizarre moments through which he has an motion film fist combat together with his therapist and pop, or a fourth wall-breaking interplay with the Bandersnatch movie crew.
Looked at as a time journey story, although, issues develop into a bit of clearer. Though the story performs with concepts of alternative, ceding free will to know-how, and looking for escapism in digital media, as a time journey story, its main focus is on obsessing over previous errors that may’t be modified. Stefan is unable to recover from his mom’s loss of life or to cease blaming his father and himself for what occurred, and that incapability is ruining his life. His obsession with making an attempt to vary that occasion solely makes issues worse.
There are loads of time journey tales that take care of those self same concepts, usually ending on the tragic notice of the primary character lastly succumbing to their obsession. In Bandersnatch, the last word conclusion would not come from Stefan fixing the past–it comes from him tragically accepting that he by no means will. What seems like the last word conclusion of the story is when, after listening to Colin, Stefan discovers that he can use a mirror to journey again to the loss of life of his mom.
With the fitting decisions, Stefan can journey again in time, find the toy, and place it the place he misplaced it, which permits five-year-old Stefan to search out it and alter the previous. But that does not imply Stefan saves his mother and fixes his life, as one would possibly count on in a extra conventional time journey story. Finding the toy would not permit Stefan’s mom to go away earlier and keep away from the prepare derailment. But replaying the second provides the viewer a brand new alternative: to let Stefan go together with her. He spends his last moments together with his mom on the doomed prepare, dying together with her as a substitute of lose her.
After all these resets, totally different paths, and alternate decisions, what looks like the end result of Bandersnatch–which is itself a bit speculative because the story might be replayed over and over–is Stefan coming to phrases together with his trauma over his mom’s loss of life. Stefan would possibly have the ability to attempt totally different decisions, however he cannot repair something by means of time journey and venturing by means of totally different realities. The solely factor he can in the end change is himself. Or slightly, Stefan realizes that he by no means will.
The attraction of the concept of time journey is in how we would alter our personal lives with the advantage of hindsight, however like most of its sci-fi ideas, Black Mirror makes use of it for a downbeat have a look at the methods we attempt to escape the issues that hurt us. Bandersnatch’s level is that the advantage of escapism, whether or not it is obsessing about the best way to repair our errors or getting misplaced in alternate worlds, is not within the escape from actuality, however what we find out about ourselves earlier than returning to it.