In 2017, entrepreneur Billy McFarland tried to placed on a fantastical music competition within the Bahamas referred to as the Fyre Festival. This elitist and really costly occasion ended up being a complete catastrophe. Now, each Netflix and Hulu have competing documentaries about this second in historical past, however which one do you have to watch?
Both of those films just about come to the identical conclusion, that occasion coordinator Billy McFarland is a functioning sociopath, compulsive liar, and a modern-day snake oil salesman. However, how each these movies come to that conclusion could be very totally different.
Netflix’s Fyre and Hulu’s Fyre Fraud recount the occasions main as much as the Fyre Festival and the way it all got here collectively, which was approach too shortly and with none skilled chief operating all of it. From having to modify the island the place it was going to be held, to FEMA tents getting used as a substitute of villas, to the bands dropping out the final minute, it’s the story of somebody who desperately desires to be one thing he’s in the end not, a tech billionaire.
Fyre, Netflix’s documentary in regards to the occasion, has a bit extra of a mature tackle the occasions and presents them as severely as potential. This is considered one of director Chris Smith’s greatest documentaries, which is saying quite a bit as he additionally directed 2017’s Jim and Andy: The Great Beyond for Netflix and 1999’s cult traditional American Movie. The story is delivered as extra of a thriller, asking the viewers, “What went wrong?” It’s obvious, from the get-go, that the issue was lack of planning and making an attempt to hurry out a product–which rests squarely on the shoulders of Billy McFarland.
The topics being interviewed for the piece are those that labored on the competition, from those who arrange the levels and “sleeping” areas to these concerned within the planning of the occasion. As the film progresses, it turns into clear that it is nothing in need of a “clusterf***,” with McFarland’s response to most issues being one thing alongside the traces of, “think positive and it will all work out.” It would not.
Fyre looks like a smashing success as it’s a splendidly engrossing film from begin to end. It is actually a rollercoaster journey of a narrative, for individuals who are solely semi-familiar with what occurred on the occasion.
Over at Hulu, Fyre Fraud nearly has a comedic bent to your complete piece, particularly with the musical cues transitioning between every scene, which is tough to soak up when the thesis for the movie is that Fyre Media founder Billy McFarland was knowingly defrauding everybody round him. Fyre Fraud lets the viewers know that every thing about this competition was part of the malicious intent that McFarland had. It’s clearly a leap away from what Netflix’s Fyre.
It feels as if Fyre Fraud is geared far more to a youthful viewers, but on the similar time, a bit of an early portion of the film focuses closely on what “celebrity influencers” and “social media” are, so decisions like which are a bit weird. Additionally, the film jumps round fairly a bit within the Fyre Festival timeline.
Fyre Fraud is far more a few Cliffsnotes model behind-the-scenes earlier than and after the event–including from people who attended the event–but the one factor Hulu’s documentary has over Netflix’s is interviews with Billy McFarland. However, it isn’t as in-depth as you could hope for. There are even parts left within the film the place McFarland states he refuses to reply questions or just says, “I don’t know.” However, the McFarland interviews alone make it value your whereas to look at Fyre Fraud. Additionally, the Hulu documentary makes it some extent point out that Jerry Media produced the Netflix documentary, and Jerry Media who had been behind the social media advertising and marketing for Fyre Fest, and for sure, Fyre Fraud shouldn’t be sort to Jerry Media, whereas Netflix’s documentary tends to color them in a significantly better gentle.
So when you can solely watch considered one of these films, which one do you select? Even understanding the truth that Jerry Media had a hand in it, Netflix’s Fyre is the way in which to go. It’s not as malicious proper off the bat in relation to the way in which it represents its subjects–or millenials as a whole–and Smith finds most likely the easiest way to inform this story with out getting too in-depth with McFarland’s life. However, each films current totally different sides of the identical story. Fyre Fraud provides the viewers extra perception into McFarland’s life, which the Netflix doc would not. So be sure to take a look at each of the films, however be sure to look at Netflix’s first, because it’s the higher one.